Jazz Controversy (AtoZ Challenge 2016 – Jazz Age Jazz)

Jazz Controversy (Jazz Age Jazz Series) When Jazz first became popular int he 1920s, a fierce debated broke out about whether it was even music. It broke with everything, classic canon of music, ways to play, instruments used. And of course, it was indecent

Jazz Age Jazz - Jazz controversy

JAZZ AGE JAZZ - Jazz Controversy #AtoZChallenge In 1920s America, #jazz didn't have it easy Click To Tweet

J - Jazz Controversy (AtoZ Challenge 2016)In the Twenties, everybody danced to jazz. Everybody listened to jazz. Musicians wanted to learn jazz. Recording industries and the showbiz wanted to make money off of jazz.
So everybody noticed jazz and started to think about jazz. Big trouble ensued.

As the popularity of jazz rose through the decade, it arose fierce opposition and hot support.
Detractors thought jazz was messy and unprofessional – when they didn’t dismissed it altogether as just noise – produced by low-class elements of society – that meant mostly African Americans – who had little or no musical education and relied on improvisation and playing ’by head’ because they could not read music.
Lovers hailed it as a profoundly new way to make music, the sound of their time, fast and exciting. A new language for a new century and a new society. They saw improvisation as the highest manifestation of freedom.
But however they thought about it, be it good or evil, critics on both sides agree that jazz was the symbol of the fundamental – and provocative – changes they were experiencing in their post-WWI urban, industrial society. It strongly connected to their time.

Dancing the Charleston

Dancing the Charleston

Detractors of jazz actually had a lot to bring to the table… so they thought.
First of all, jazz was clearly evil since it had first emerged in shady places, like brothels and honky tonks. And as the Teens turned into the Twenties, it didn’t go any better. Jazz would be performed mostly in nightclubs and speakeasies, establishments that were notoriously tide to bootlegging rings. Many performers found themselves on gangsters’ payroll. Bad.
Black-and-tan clubs would allowed both black and white patrons and in some of these establishments there was no restriction to free mixing and dancing. Very bad.

If this were not enough, jazz was thought to be barbaric, to take down moral barriers and stimulate sexual activity. Besides the dances that jazz inspired were quite plainly very sexy. This was of course a great danger for young people, most of all women. Who, by the way, were never allowed into saloons, but now frequented speakeasies, drank and danced, just like – and together with – men. Very very bad.
As jazz became ever more popular, community groups as well as groups of private citizens asked for a regulation of the music. In 1927 the Government finally issued the Radio Act, which encouraged the transmission of sanitized jazz rather than the more lively, more cutting age jazz played in nightclubs.
By the end of the 1920s, at least 60 communities across the United State had enacted laws prohibiting jazz from public halls.

One would think jazz was only music, after all. But detractors seem to fear jazz because it was different. It featured improvisation over tradition, performer over composer, and black American expression over conventional white sensibility. In short, it was subversive. But it was the language of a new era and a new society and they could not snuff it.




Ogren, Kathy J., The Jazz Revolution. Twenties America and the Meaning of Jazz. Oxford University Press, New York, 1989

PBS – The Devil’s Music: 1920s Jazz
Quora – Why was jazz ocnsidered the devil’s music?


Give in to the Feeling (Sarah Zama) Banner

SmashwordsBarnes&Nobles | KoboiBookStore
And many other stores

FREE EBOOK - The Roaring Twenties A to Z

Subscribe to The Old Shelter mailing list and get this 56-pages FREE pdf

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

About the Author

I was born, raised and I still live near Verona (Italy), though I worked for a time in Dublin. I started writing fantasy stories as a kid. Today I’m a bookseller who reads fantasy, history, mythology, anthropology and lots of speculative fiction. Somehow, all of this has found its way into my own dieselpunk stories.

36 Comments on "Jazz Controversy (AtoZ Challenge 2016 – Jazz Age Jazz)"

  1. I am enjoying this immensely!
    Don’t let up! Keep it loud! Make it Jass! 🙂

    Sir Leprechaunrabbit
    Sir Leprechaunrabbit recently posted…INTERPOLMy Profile

  2. hahahaa! these complaints seem so archaic today! of course, have you seen young people dance? it looks less like sex and more like convulsions.
    PammyPam recently posted…Bad Girls Book Club Letter I #atozchallenge The impossible knife of Memory and I am MalalaMy Profile

  3. J here, of the #atozchallenge Arlee Bird’s A to Z Ambassador Team. Thanks for stopping by Arlee’s blog to comment on my Manhattan story.
    How has the first week of the challenge been for you so far? Are you meeting your goals of posting and hopping to other blogs? Looking forward to Sunday off?
    My blog’s giveaways are still going!
    I love that barbaric music! Funny how now it’s mostly considered a cultural, calm sort of music.
    J Lenni Dorner recently posted…#atozchallenge I is for Insecure #WriteTip #IWSG Use the Zodiac @JunetaKey #CharacterSheetMy Profile

    • Yeah, but jazz as we listen to today is quite different from what it used to be in the 1920s. It’s more mellow, and I don’t think performances look anything like they used to be in the 1920s.
      Though I jazzman I know (he’s Italian) frequents Nigerian clubs here in Verona and what he tells me about those – the kind of music and the kind of musicians/audience interaction – sounds a lot like what I’ve read about 1920s jazz.
      Weird, eh?

  4. The establishment always fears what it cannot control and it clearly could not control jazz.
    Tasha’s Thinkings | Wittegen Press | FB3X (AC)
    Tasha recently posted…J – Jacob Marley & Shoeless Joe Jackson – Fictional Phantoms #AtoZChallenge 2016My Profile

  5. Great stuff! 🙂

  6. Jazz was the beginning of the end… the slippery slope that led to even more depravity… to Rock N’ Roll. Now in my day we did the waltz, but then that was considered almost outrageous.

    The truth: love them all and glad society rebelled and embraced them. Innovation is always seen as rebellion. Just don’t forget what a crank does.
    Roland Clarke recently posted…J for Jamila – #atozchallengeMy Profile

  7. I don’t know if you follow DOWNTON ABBEY but I especially loved their segments during the Jazz Age. Hard for the older folks to adjust to!!!

    Meet My Imaginary Friends
    #AtoZchallenge http://www.kathleenvalentineblog.com/
    Kathleen Valentine recently posted…J is for Jake: Blogging the #AtoZchallengeMy Profile

    • Actually, I’ve never followed that show, but I do know about it. ‘Jazz Age’ in Britain had a lot in common with American ‘Jazz Age’, from what I know. It was kind of different in continental Europe.

  8. It’s good to know Jazz won out. I love the music in all it’s many forms.
    So, thinking of a ‘J’ letter for this challenge was a piece of cake for you I think. LOL
    Jeffrey Scott recently posted…Nostalgia TV – JMy Profile

  9. Loved this post! So informative and fun! I’m learning so much!!!!!
    Tawnya recently posted…A to Z- Authentic Inspiration: Journeys #atozchallengeMy Profile

  10. I feel like jazz is interwoven with women’s issues, definitely–for the first time, we were wearing shorter skirts, drinking, and dancing. Scandalous!
    Megan Morgan recently posted…J – JargonMy Profile

    • I feel like jazz in the 1920s was interwoven with most of what was changing. Not just women, but also African American awareness and freedom of expression. Facing a new life with different rhythms and expectations. Looking toward the future, rather than the past.
      This is why jazz was so influential in the Jazz Age, I believe. It was not just about music. It was about an entire system of living.

  11. Your description of Jazz in the 1920s is reminiscent of Rock and Roll in the 1950s. Plus ça change plus c’est la même chose. (The more things change the more they stay the same.) This was a great read. Thanks! 🙂
    Debbie D recently posted…J is for JACK RUSSELL TERRIER | #AtoZChallengeMy Profile

    • Yes, as I’ve stated before, I believe 1920s jazz and 1950s rock n’ roll had a lot in common. Both were not just about music. They impacted an entire society.

  12. Like Rock and Roll in the 50’s, Jazz was misunderstood and seen as decadent. The Nazis banned jazz as being non-Aryan music.

    Arlee Bird
    A to Z Challenge Co-host
    Arlee Bird recently posted…Jobs in Manhattan (#atozchallenge)My Profile

    • And yet, it appears that the Nazis loved jazz too. I’ve heard that some Nazi hierarches had private jazz sessions performed specifically for them and their friends and guests.
      It’s definitelly a very complex matter.

  13. It is all kinds of ironic that in an era of blatant racism people would think that sex, music, and dancing were the greatest threat to society… XD I bet some people still think that way.

    @TarkabarkaHolgy from
    The Multicolored Diary
    Tarkabarka recently posted…J is for Jovial in-lawsMy Profile

    • Well, I believe you’re mistaken. It wasn’t sex and dances the greatest threat to society. It was alcohol. I mean, they passed a ‘law’ against it 😉

  14. I love that you included info about the controversy around jazz! It hasn’t always been revered and appreciated.
    Sabina recently posted…JesterMy Profile

    • This was the agrument that really prompted the theme for this year’s challenge.
      If you are interested in this, I’d reccomand Ogren’s book ‘The Jazz Revolution’, to which this theme is inspired. Truely intersting stuff 🙂

  15. It’s always interesting to look back on what people of previous generations considered unacceptable, low-bred, too sexy, etc. In my own lifetime, I remember music videos like “Erotica” and “Justify My Love” being banned or only shown at certain hours, and yet today they seem so tame and tasteful. I don’t want to imagine what might someday make today’s hypersexual rap songs and ultra-violent movies look tame!
    Carrie-Anne recently posted…The Jordan Staircase and JoyMy Profile

    • I suppose society gets accustomed to everything. And while sometimes this is a good thing, some other times it isn’t.
      But then that’s why being aware of the past is so important: it help to create a perspective.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: